Showing posts with label mediabias. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mediabias. Show all posts

Monday, July 21, 2014

speculative reporting

To: feedback@firstpost.com, complaint@network18online.com, News Broadcasting Standards Authority <authority@nbanewdelhi.com>

Sir/Madam

I would like to draw your attention to the Firstpost article with headline: "Return of AAP tamasha: To sit at Rajghat to 'pray for clean politics'"

http://www.firstpost.com/india/return-of-aap-tamasha-to-sit-at-rajghat-to-pray-for-clean-politics-1627367.html

Whereas the headline prominently uses the word "tamasha", the content of the article nowhere argues how AAP's action is a tamasha, thus speculative reporting. If such writing made sense, anybody can call any action as tamasha without reason.

The headline can cause wrongful damage to AAP's reputation and thus I request that it be removed with utmost urgency and an apology be issued about speculative reporting.I would appreciate a swift reply and action from you.

Regards,

Misleading TOI Report

To: News Broadcasting Standards Authority <authority@nbanewdelhi.com>, grievance.toi@timesinternet.in, PCI complaints <pcibppcomplaint@gmail.com>
 
Sir/Madam

I would like to bring the following headline to your notice: "AAP ticket for ex-officer who reversed Khemka orders":

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/AAP-ticket-for-ex-officer-who-reversed-Khemka-orders/articleshow/31864862.cms

The article has mixed 2 different topics---Rozka-Gujar land consolidation and Vadra-DLF deal. Particularly on Vadra-DLF deal, the content of the article is contradictory to the following assertion made as caption of a picture within the article "... Yudhbir Singh Khyalia overturned after Khemka was transferred out." Infact, the article later says "Khyalia had stood by Khemka's order on the Vadra-DLF land deal. He had told the Haryana government that the basis of Khemka's decision to cancel the mutation was correct."

There is nothing in the article that indicates that the Rozka-Gujar issue is important enough to merit as adequate reason for this headline. The article, and more importantly the headline, is very misleading since a reader would wrongly interpret that Khyalia reversed the much-talked about Vadra-DLF-related order of Dr Khemka. The article can cause wrongful damage to AAP's reputation and thus I request that it be removed with utmost urgency and an apology be issued about incorrect/misleading reporting.


I would appreciate a swift reply and action from you.

Regards,

Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Lok Sabha 2014: Violation of Model Code of Conduct

ETV News broadcast a video titled "Narendra Modi`s Mother Travels In Auto To Cast Vote" depicting Modi's mother as casting vote for BJP on the electronic voting machine (EVM). The choice of symbol made by the voter on EVM is clearly visible on the video. The video can be seen at: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQ3fkwkyRh4 

Isn't such broadcast a violation of model code of conduct (in particular section 126 of RPA)? I request EC to file a FIR on this issue. 

Related post: http://bangalorelivediaries.blogspot.in/2014/04/bangalore-code-of-conduct-violated-by.html

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Complaint: Speculative Reporting

Date: April 11, 2014

To: News Broadcasting Standards Authority <authority@nbanewdelhi.com>,
 Kshipra.jatana@network18online.com,
 complaint@network18online.com


Sir/Madam

I would like to bring the following headline to your notice: "Varanasi: AAP may join hands with jailed Mukhtar Ansari to defeat Modi"

http://ibnlive.in.com/news/varanasi-aap-may-join-hands-with-jailed-mukhtar-ansari-to-defeat-modi/464267-81.html

There is nothing in the article that indicates any statement from an AAP spokesperson about possible collaboration ("joining hands") with Mukhtar Ansari. Thus, the article, and more importantly the headline, is based purely on speculation.

The article can wrongly cause wrongful damage to AAP's reputation and thus
I request that it be removed with utmost urgency and an apology be issued about speculative reporting.

I would appreciate a swift reply and action from you.

Regards,
-Amit Kumar
Bangalore


Sunday, March 16, 2014

Irresponsible Reporting/Writing

to: p.sibbal@nic.in,
 pcibpp@gmail.com,
 pcimeetings@gmail.com,
 pcibppcomplaint@gmail.com,
 pcibpplib@gmail.com,
 pcibppeditorial@gmail.com,
 pcibppaccount@gmail.com,
 pcibpphindi@gmail.com,
 pcibppadmin@gmail.com,
 justicekatju@gmail.com
cc: r.jagannathan@network18online.com

Dear Sirs/Madams

I refer to Mr Jagannathan's article here: http://www.firstpost.com/politics/kejriwals-tactics-are-up-against-law-of-diminishing-returns-1435789.html

The author wrote in the introduction of the article:

By claiming yesterday (14 March) that the whole of the media is paid and that he will send some of them to jail if he comes to power, he is teetering on the brink of becoming a failed politician and, worse, leader.

(part of text was highlighted by me)
The text in the article cites a video that has no evidence of Kejriwal having actually said the alleged statement; instead it features Kejriwal denying he ever said that the whole of media is paid.

However, instead of investigating and establishing the validity of the alleged statement, the author decided to base the whole of the article on this false premise. 

Is such carelessness or lack of quality expected from a senior respected journalist? I hope the media guild does some introspection, since it is clear from current events that this is not a solitary or even uncommon example of careless writing. Please act before it is too late.