Showing posts with label india. Show all posts
Showing posts with label india. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Saturday, April 19, 2014

Bangalore: Code of Conduct Violated by BJP

TOI Bangalore published a full-page front page advertisement for BJP on April 17, the day of election in Bangalore. This is a blatant violation of Sec 126 of RPA 1951:

Candidate can not display to the public any election matter by means of cinematograph, television or other similar apparatus during the period of 48 hours ending with the hour fixed for the conclusion of poll.
(Refer: Sec. 126 of Representation of People Act, 1951)

It should be noted that ECI has responded to similar cases elsewhere, e.g., http://odishasuntimes.com/47212/ec-slap-showcause-notice-bjd-bjp/ .

FYI, this matter has been discussed on the online forum at:

https://www.quora.com/Politics-of-India-1/This-was-in-the-paper-today-in-Bangalore-Doesnt-this-violate-the-Election-Code-of-Conduct

I request EC to take appropriate steps against the violation of code of conduct. 
Update: I made this complaint to EC via http://eci-citizenservices.nic.in/. But, the EC disposed off the complaint giving "action taken" as "forwarded to aro XXXX". Effectively, they disposed off the complaint without any concrete action, whereas they could have marked the complaint status as pending. In response, I made a new complaint with the following text: 

My earlier online complaint number XXXXXX was "disposed" without resolution. First, the action taken as listed on the complaint is "forwarded to aro XXXX ". Now, since the complaint was about advertisement in TOI Bangalore on polling day, I do not see how the ARO will resolve it. Second, more importantly, since no concrete action has been taken by EC, the resolution status should have been marked to "Interim Action Taken Complaint Pending". How can a simple forward from one department of EC to another be disposal of the complaint? I request EC to 1) correct the resolution status of complaint number XXXXXX to a non-disposed status. 2) take concrete action on the complaint, not forwarded it from one office to another before marking the complaint as "disposed".
To my dismay, even this complaint was disposed off with the same "action taken", i.e., "forwarded to aro XXXX"! Since then, I have posted the second complaint multiple times (and will keep doing so every day till resolved), and it has been disposed with the same "action taken" every time.

 

Thursday, April 17, 2014

I Stand for Compulsory Voting. Why?

For these reasons:
  1. It is one of the easier reforms to implement since: 
    • Election Commission already have almost all citizens within electoral rolls. Unlikely to be too expensive to implement.
    • There seems to be a political consensus building on the need of this reform.
  2. Compulsory voting will encourage participation from young, urban and other voters. It will strengthen democracy.
  3. Election fraud, e.g., repeat voting, irregularities such as missing names from electoral rolls, etc., will have to be drastically reduced.
  4. There are very few arguments against compulsory voting. One argument seems to be along the lines of "right to be undisciplined citizen" but the constitution does not guarantee such as right. A citizen can exercise NOTA option if no candidate is found to be adequate.
The underlying issue of substance is what would be the punishment for not voting. Examples from other countries like Singapore that already implement compulsory voting can serve as models.

References:
  • http://www.firstpost.com/politics/compulsory-voting-will-draw-young-voters-and-is-welcome-loksatta-chief-1118239.html
  • http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/advani-backs-modi-idea-of-compulsory-voting/1179261/

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Gender Bias in India

I have witnessed the issue of Gender Bias in top private MNCs in Bangalore, the so-called Silicon Valley (Plateau) of India. The situation is deplorable even in the highly progressive sectors of India, let alone what happens elsewhere.

An example is that an unprofessional male manager forms a small "peer group" from within his team consisting only of his male friends. This peer group meets outside office on beer parties and the like, and also discuss important issues related to the job, and the discussions are not informed to people outside the peer group. Currently there are little-to-no legal mechanisms to restrain such unprofessional behavior by the manager.

Not only women form a small percentage of employees within many teams and companies, but also in some of these companies it is very difficult for a woman to rise to a leadership position.

People from all diverse backgrounds, e.g., people from other states, also face discrimination at workplace. Thus, I will shortly be drafting a PIL regarding institutionalizing diversity in workplace. It will contain the following issues:

Short-term Measures
  1. Every India-based company should be required to set-up an India-based Ethics Committee that will work independently of the company, and handle complaints related to gender and other kinds of bias, ethics violations, etc., reported by employees and other stakeholders.
Long-term Measures
  1. Corporates above a certain size, say 500 employees or $10 million annual revenue, should be asked to measure and improve their diversity index, and publicly publish them. The diversity index should contain factors such as % of women, % of people from other states, etc. Periodically, the companies with poor diversity index/negative change in diversity index should be asked:
    1. Why could they not hire people from diverse backgrounds?
  2. Companies with good diversity index among peers should be awarded prizes of appreciation. 

Complaint: Speculative Reporting

Date: April 11, 2014

To: News Broadcasting Standards Authority <authority@nbanewdelhi.com>,
 Kshipra.jatana@network18online.com,
 complaint@network18online.com


Sir/Madam

I would like to bring the following headline to your notice: "Varanasi: AAP may join hands with jailed Mukhtar Ansari to defeat Modi"

http://ibnlive.in.com/news/varanasi-aap-may-join-hands-with-jailed-mukhtar-ansari-to-defeat-modi/464267-81.html

There is nothing in the article that indicates any statement from an AAP spokesperson about possible collaboration ("joining hands") with Mukhtar Ansari. Thus, the article, and more importantly the headline, is based purely on speculation.

The article can wrongly cause wrongful damage to AAP's reputation and thus
I request that it be removed with utmost urgency and an apology be issued about speculative reporting.

I would appreciate a swift reply and action from you.

Regards,
-Amit Kumar
Bangalore


Thursday, April 10, 2014

Easy RTI Application / Online

No need to run around in your town/city to just to make a Right to Information Act 2005 (RTI) application. Thanks to http://onlinerti.com/ it is possible to make an RTI application online from your desk.

I have just now submitted my first RTI application via this website. Thus, my experience with the site is still new. I will update this blog post to include more information in the future.

Filing an Application
 
The website is pretty simple and effective. However, at the time of writing one must be careful while using the website since the "Previous" button is not working. Payment of Rs 99 has be made via internet banking or credit/debit card.

Guide to drafting a good RTI application

http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/blogs/karira/4403-guide-drafting-good-rti-application.htm



Saturday, March 29, 2014

Is "Press Freedom Index" biased against populous countries like India?

 index@rsf.org,
 pcibpp@gmail.com,
 pcimeetings@gmail.com,
 PCI Complaints Complaint <pcibppcomplaint@gmail.com>,
 markandey katju <justicekatju@gmail.com>


Dear Madams/Sirs
The much-quoted (e.g., see [1-3]) Press Freedom Index ranked India at 140 in 2014.

As per the methodology [4] linked from the Index website [5], the number of violent incidents against journalists is used as a contributing factor for computing this index. However, there is no normalization by country size! This leads to a clear bias against populous countries that naturally are likely to have more such unfortunate incidents due to their larger size.
I could not perform more detailed investigation since I could not avail of the detailed computation used in computing the scores for India and other large countries from the website. Thus, the degree of contribution of the above reason in the overall scores is still unclear.