Sunday, March 16, 2014

Irresponsible Reporting/Writing

to: p.sibbal@nic.in,
 pcibpp@gmail.com,
 pcimeetings@gmail.com,
 pcibppcomplaint@gmail.com,
 pcibpplib@gmail.com,
 pcibppeditorial@gmail.com,
 pcibppaccount@gmail.com,
 pcibpphindi@gmail.com,
 pcibppadmin@gmail.com,
 justicekatju@gmail.com
cc: r.jagannathan@network18online.com

Dear Sirs/Madams

I refer to Mr Jagannathan's article here: http://www.firstpost.com/politics/kejriwals-tactics-are-up-against-law-of-diminishing-returns-1435789.html

The author wrote in the introduction of the article:

By claiming yesterday (14 March) that the whole of the media is paid and that he will send some of them to jail if he comes to power, he is teetering on the brink of becoming a failed politician and, worse, leader.

(part of text was highlighted by me)
The text in the article cites a video that has no evidence of Kejriwal having actually said the alleged statement; instead it features Kejriwal denying he ever said that the whole of media is paid.

However, instead of investigating and establishing the validity of the alleged statement, the author decided to base the whole of the article on this false premise. 

Is such carelessness or lack of quality expected from a senior respected journalist? I hope the media guild does some introspection, since it is clear from current events that this is not a solitary or even uncommon example of careless writing. Please act before it is too late.


Update: After my complaint the author of the article updated the post with links of a video that he claims contains parts where AK says "the whole of media is paid".

Actually, this is highly debatable since one line was picked out of context from AK's speech, and AK has himself denied having made such a statement.

However, I could not follow up further with this issue since there are many other things to handle as well.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thanks for your comment. I appreciate your time. Your comment will be moderated, and in most cases, published without modification.