Saturday, March 29, 2014

Is "Press Freedom Index" biased against populous countries like India?

 index@rsf.org,
 pcibpp@gmail.com,
 pcimeetings@gmail.com,
 PCI Complaints Complaint <pcibppcomplaint@gmail.com>,
 markandey katju <justicekatju@gmail.com>


Dear Madams/Sirs
The much-quoted (e.g., see [1-3]) Press Freedom Index ranked India at 140 in 2014.

As per the methodology [4] linked from the Index website [5], the number of violent incidents against journalists is used as a contributing factor for computing this index. However, there is no normalization by country size! This leads to a clear bias against populous countries that naturally are likely to have more such unfortunate incidents due to their larger size.
I could not perform more detailed investigation since I could not avail of the detailed computation used in computing the scores for India and other large countries from the website. Thus, the degree of contribution of the above reason in the overall scores is still unclear.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thanks for your comment. I appreciate your time. Your comment will be moderated, and in most cases, published without modification.